Written By: Mariah Sager '18
Published November 2014
On October 7th, Dr. Ashok Roy, Director of Collections at the National Gallery in London, visited Randolph College. He gave three lectures, and met with small groups of students in two private lunches. Some art and art history professors took advantage of this opportunity by requiring class attendance at the lectures, or encouraging students to attend the lunches with Dr. Roy. His visit marks the first event of the College’s budding partnership with the National Gallery, which began in February of this year after the sale of the Maier’s George Bellows painting Men of the Docks to the museum, making Randolph the only educational institution in the United States with such a relationship to the Gallery. President Bateman said that “Dr. Roy turned out be an excellent public speaker and a gracious and engaging person. I think that the success of the many events that we hosted the week he was here was a great way to start the partnership.”
Although
visits from museum staff are to be arranged by the administration, faculty and
staff members have their own hopes for the partnership. According to President
Bateman, an exhibit in the Maier Museum of pieces lent by the National Gallery
may be in the making. “There are some very technical conditions we have to
meet,” he says, such as certain humidity and temperature requirements, but
“we’re very optimistic.” The loan being discussed at the moment is to be of
Renaissance works. In addition, the National Gallery will be offering
internships to Randolph students. This is exclusive to our partnership: the
museum does not allow any other students to hold such a position. Dr. Leanne
Zalewski, Assistant Professor of Art, says that “students are very excited
about the internship opportunity.” This opportunity is not exclusive to art
history students. Dr. Roy himself is a chemist, and students of all majors,
from Chemistry to Communications, could benefit. These internships, because
they must be in London, will most likely take place in the summer rather than
during a semester. Moreover, the National Gallery has said to President Bateman
that “they are interested in selecting from among the interns that we send each
year to invite one of them back for a ten-month paid position the following
year.” This opportunity was not laid out in the original contract, which has
turned out to be very flexible: says Bateman, “[the partnership] is ending up
being even richer and providing more opportunities for our students than we had
initially imagined.”
For
instance, Randolph may be able, on occasion, to borrow Men of the Docks from the National Gallery. Randolph
will also be holding a reception for alumnae and alumni at the National Gallery
in London in mid-July. The contract with the museum allows the College to hold
such receptions several times in the first ten years of the partnership, at no
cost.
This partnership started with a process begun in 2007, when the
Maier Museum put this work on auction. Men
of the Docks, created in
1912, was one of the Maier’s first acquisitions. It was bought directly from
Bellows for $2,500 in 1920 and had for many decades been the centerpiece of
Randolph’s collection: Scott Jaschik of the website Inside Higher Ed called it
“by far the most valuable and artistically significant” piece in the Maier
Museum. When the College decided to sell the painting, it then received a lot
of backlash. Both the museum’s director, Karol Lawson, and associate director,
Ellen Agnew, resigned from their positions in protest. The College Art
Association said that “Randolph College has compromised the educational and
cultural mission of the [Maier] by treating its collection as a fungible asset
rather than as a vital part of the institution’s artistic heritage,” and Lee
Rosenbaum, art journalist and blogger, proclaimed “shame on Randolph
College.”
Furthermore,
the American Alliance of Museums (AAM), which includes 3,500 institutions,
blacklisted Randolph, prohibiting the Maier from borrowing works from other
college museums. The AAM called the sale of the painting a “flagrant, egregious
violation of our Code of Ethics for Museums” and said that it threatened the
“lofty status” of museums throughout the world as collections held in the
public trust. As Scott Jaschik writes, “the policies of several art and museum
groups state that museums should sell art only to buy more art, not to improve
their finances.” The sale of Men
of the Docks did not benefit
the Maier, but the $25.5 million profit went instead to the college’s
endowment.
However,
Randolph is not the only college to make such a move. In 1991, Brandeis
University auctioned off eleven works to cushion their endowment. The Memphis
College of Art decided in 2012 to sell much of their collection, including
works by artists such as Roy Lichtenstein and Andy Warhol, to increase their
finances. Fisk University sold a fifty-percent share of a collection they had
been given by Georgia O’Keeffe, which included four pieces by the Modernist
painter herself, as well as artists like Picasso, Cézanne, and Renoir, in order
to raise $30 million for their endowment.
President
Bateman, who had not yet begun his tenure as College president when the sale
took place, said in February 2014 that Randolph “is a college, not a museum,”
and that “the primary fiduciary responsibility of the college’s Board of
Trustees,” which decided to sell the painting, “is to provide the highest
quality liberal education available.” In 2007, the Southern Association of
Colleges and Schools issued Randolph a financial warning, and the profit from
the painting was a significant addition to its endowment, which was around $136
million in 2013. Bateman says of the College’s partnership with the National
Gallery, “This is a remarkable opportunity to keep our connection to the
Bellows and have it in a place where the public can see it while at the same
time make a big step toward becoming financially sustainable.”
George
Bellows himself might not have been in opposition to the sale; according to Lee
Rosenbaum, a Maier Museum newsletter from 2007 stated that T. Moody Campbell,
one of the professors involved in the purchase of the painting, said that
Bellows thought “most artists, he being one of them, were [most concerned]
about having [their paintings] in a place where they would be
appreciated.” The National Gallery in London garners six million
visitors, of which one million are American, every year, meaning Men of the Docks will be viewed by many more people
than it previously has been, but many Randolph students, faculty, staff, and
alums feel the absence of the painting in the Maier Museum as a great loss,
both personally and to the College. According to Abigail Gautreau ’06, Men of the Docks was selected by Randolph-Macon Woman’s
College’s very first art professor, Louise Jordan Smith. She, along with a
German professor, founded The Randolph-Macon Art Association of Lynchburg, “a
coalition of students, faculty, alumnae, and local townspeople” who raised the
funds necessary to purchase the painting. She says, “It was the first
masterpiece in the collection. Men
of the Docks was not simply
another valuable piece in a large collection; it was one of the first, and it
had special meaning attached to it due to the circumstances of its
acquisition.”
In spite
of the controversy surrounding the sale of the Bellows painting, the fact
remains that students and faculty are already benefitting from the partnership
between Randolph College and the National Gallery. The lectures by Dr. Roy
offered tangible evidence of this benefit. Dr. Roy is a conservator who studies
technology used in art conservation and restoration such as x-radiography and
pigment sampling and analysis. The lectures included one titled “F for Fake, R
for Real: The Fall and Rise of Two Madonnas,” which discussed how such
technologies are used to “confirm, and sometimes contest, the identity of the
artist credited with a work of art,” specifically speaking on two Italian
Renaissance paintings housed in the National Gallery.
In his
other lectures, he addressed the issue of the stability of color pigments and
“the technical analysis of a Renoir painting and its impact on our understanding
of the work.” Students, faculty, and others in the Randolph community can look
forward to similar visits in the future by National Gallery staff, and there
were four applicants for the first internship positions that will take place in
London. “I think it’s a wonderful opportunity for our students and a great
opportunity for us to be able to showcase the excellent students that we have
here at Randolph,” beamed President Bateman.